Amara Cay Resort

Costco Member Reviews

Costco Star Rating

3.5 Star Hotel

80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL, 33036, United States

This beachfront oasis on the sunrise side of Islamorada is a destination in itself. Reflecting the easy tranquility of the Upper Keys, the oceanfront resort seamlessly blends recreation with relaxation. Guests of the Islamorada Resort Collection have access to unique amenities, events and restaurants of four resorts in Islamorada. Complimentary shuttle service is available between each resort and nearby attractions.

Executive Member Benefit

Executive Members receive an annual 2% Reward, up to $1,250, on qualified Costco Travel purchases

Hotel Details

Overview

Hotel Description

Reflecting the easy tranquility of the keys, Amara Cay seamlessly blends its guests’ need for recreation with a generous dose of relaxation. Featuring a tiki bar, pool, marina, lawn games, and the wonders of nature with eco-boat tours, snorkeling, kayaking and biking. All rooms are decorated in fresh, natural hues of Islamorada and equipped with an incredible selection of amenities. Each room and suite is infused with the easy elegance of the tropics, and comes with one king or two queen beds that include premium bedding and triple sheeting, as well as plush bathrobes.

Key Features

Distance from Airport: 80 Miles
Distance from Airport: 90 Minutes
Area: Islamorada, Village of Islands in the Florida Keys, approximately from mile marker 90 to 72. Islamorada is a tourism-oriented community an hour south of Miami consisting of four islands spanning 18 linear miles with a land area of approximately 3,900 acres.
Number of Rooms: 110
Number of Floors: 4
Elevator(s)
Last Renovation: 2018
Check-In Time: 4:00 p.m.
Check-Out Time: 11:00 a.m.
Wheelchair-Accessible Room(s) Available
Minimum Age to Stay Without an Adult: 21
Nonsmoking Property

Property
- FEATURES
- ACTIVITIES
Features
Air-Conditioning in Public Areas
Activities/Tour Desk
ATM
Bar(s)
Beach (nonswimmable)
Business Center
Conference Room(s)
Dry Cleaning
Gift Shop/Boutique
Health/Fitness Facility
Hot Tub/Jacuzzi
Internet Access (wireless)
Internet Center
Medical Facility (nearby)
Parking (self)
Restaurant(s)
Room Service
Activities
Bicycles
Board Games
Kayaking
Restaurants (nearby)
Scuba Diving
Shopping (nearby)
Shuffleboard
Snorkeling
Table Tennis
Volleyball
Windsurfing
Yoga

Dining

ReelCatch: Islamorada’s gathering spot for fun and adventure, on-site restaurant ReelCatch anchors locals and guests alike with island favorites, fresh fish and Keys-inspired cocktails.

Air-Conditioned
Meals Served: Lunch | Dinner
Menu Type: A la carte
Children's Menu Available
Reservations: Not Required
Cuisine Type: American | Seafood

Coastal Cup & Lounge: From coffee to cocktails, Coastal Cup & Lounge is where guests and locals go to start and end their days. Wake up and enjoy specialty coffees and delicious pastries, then return in the evening for refreshing drinks and tapas accompanied by acoustic sounds from local musicians.

Air-Conditioned
Meals Served: Breakfast
Menu Type: A la carte
Reservations: Not Required
Cuisine Type: American

Tiki Bar: Oceanfront and poolside, Tiki Bar at Amara Cay is the authentic Keys spot for American cuisine amongst the background of blue skies and swaying palm trees.

Meals Served: Lunch | Dinner
Menu Type: A la carte
Children's Menu Available
Reservations: Not Required
Cuisine Type: American | Seafood

Rooms
Decorated in fresh, natural hues of Islamorada and equipped with an incredible selection of amenities, each room and suite is infused with the easy elegance of the tropics and comes with one king or two queen beds that include premium bedding and triple sheeting, as well as plush bathrobes. Housekeeping is available on a request basis. All accommodations are entirely smoke-free.
Available in All Rooms:
- Coffee/Tea Maker
- Hair Dryer
- Internet Access (high-speed)
- Internet Access (wireless)
- Iron/Ironing Board
- Microwave
- Satellite/Cable TV
- Radio
- Housekeeping - Twice Weekly
- Housekeeping - Three Times Weekly
- Housekeeping - Weekly
- Standard Room - One King Bed
  Enjoy luxurious premium bedding, a private balcony and more in a Standard Room, and melt away any worries with the relaxing Keys-inspired design.
  Balcony/Lanai
  Approximate Square Feet: 292 - 410
  Bedding: King
- Standard Room - Two Queen Beds
  Enjoy luxurious premium bedding, a private balcony and more in a Standard Room, and melt away any worries with the relaxing Keys-inspired design.
  Balcony/Lanai
  Approximate Square Feet: 292 - 410
  Bedding: Two Queens
- Standard-View Studio Suite - One King Bed
  Chic coastal style welcomes you to this studio suite featuring one king bed, floor-to-ceiling window, a kitchenette and dining table.
  Approximate Square Feet: 252
  Bedding: King
- Matacumbe Courtyard-View Room with Lanai - One King Bed
  This scenic, courtyard-view room features premium bedding with plush pillows as well as upscale toiletries and a coffee maker. Room also offers comfortable accommodations and a private walk-out covered patio.
  Balcony/Lanai
  Approximate Square Feet: 264
  Bedding: King
- Matacumbe Courtyard-View Room with Lanai - Two Queen Beds
  This scenic, courtyard-view room features premium bedding with plush pillows as well as upscale toiletries and a coffee maker. Room also offers comfortable accommodations and a private walk-out covered patio.
  Balcony/Lanai
  Approximate Square Feet: 264
  Bedding: Two Queens
- Alligator Reef Partial-Ocean-View Room - One King Bed
  This elegant room features premium bedding with plush pillows, upscale toiletries and a coffee maker. Listen to the palm trees rustle in the air, feel the Keys atmosphere and take in the partial-ocean view from the private balcony.
  Balcony/Lanai
  Approximate Square Feet: 252
  Bedding: King
- Alligator Reef Partial-Ocean-View Room - Two Queen Beds
  This elegant room features premium bedding with plush pillows, upscale toiletries and a coffee maker. Listen to the palm trees rustle in the air, feel the Keys atmosphere and take in the partial-ocean view from the private balcony.
  Balcony/Lanai
  Approximate Square Feet: 252
  Bedding: Two Queens
- Alligator Reef Oceanfront Room – One King Bed
  Escape to beach bliss in this stunning oceanfront room. Rooms have a private furnished balcony, premium bedding with triple sheeting, upscale toiletries and generous workspaces with a 32” high-definition television, cordless phone and alarm clock radio.
  Balcony/Lanai
  Approximate Square Feet: 378
  Bedding: King and Sofa Bed
- Alligator Reef Oceanfront Room - Two Queen Beds
  Escape to beach bliss in this stunning oceanfront room. Rooms have a private furnished balcony, premium bedding with triple sheeting, upscale toiletries and generous workspaces with a 32” high-definition television, cordless phone and alarm clock radio.
  Balcony/Lanai
  Approximate Square Feet: 378
  Bedding: Two Queens
- One-Bedroom Standard-View Suite - One King Bed
  Enjoy calming resort views from this sophisticated one-bedroom suite, featuring one king bed and a queen-size sofa bed in a welcoming, coastal chic living space with a private balcony.
  Balcony/Lanai
  Approximate Square Feet: 431
  Bedding: King and Sofa Bed
- One-Bedroom Standard-View Suite - Two Queen Beds
  Walk out on your private balcony and embrace sound of palms rustling in warm Keys breezes. This one-bedroom suite features two queen beds, plus a queen-size sofa bed in the main living area. Enjoy the convenience of a chic kitchenette and wooden dining room table.
  Balcony/Lanai
  Approximate Square Feet: 576
  Bedding: Two Queens and a Sofa Bed
- One-Bedroom Standard-View Sunrise Suite
  Enjoy the shimmering ocean vistas from this cozy yet sophisticated studio suite that features premium bedding and a queen-size sofa bed, in addition to a coastal chic living area.
  Approximate Square Feet: 468
  Bedding: King and Sofa Bed
- One-Bedroom Oceanfront Sunrise Suite - One King Bed
  Wake up to the beautiful view of the ocean each morning, and watch the sunrise in this elegant suite that features premium bedding complimented by plush pillows. This oceanfront suite comes with upscale toiletries and a coffee maker, including a queen-size sofa bed.
  Balcony/Lanai in some rooms
  Approximate Square Feet: 888
  Bedding: King and Sofa Bed
- One-Bedroom Oceanfront Sunrise Suite - Two Queen Beds
  Wake up to the beautiful view of the ocean each morning, and watch the sunrise in this elegant suite that features premium bedding complimented by plush pillows. This oceanfront suite comes with upscale toiletries and a coffee maker, including a queen-size sofa bed.
  Approximate Square Feet: 888
  Bedding: Two Queens and a Sofa Bed
- One-Bedroom Oceanfront Sunrise Suite with Lanai - Two Queen Beds
  Unmatched ocean views await in this spacious one-bedroom suite with two premium queen beds. The main living area offers access to a private oceanfront patio, queen sofa bed and loveseat, and a kitchenette and dining table.
  Balcony/Lanai
  Approximate Square Feet: 650
  Bedding: Two Queens and a Sofa Bed

Map
Not Selected Selected

Costco Member Reviews

Costco Travel makes every effort to verify the accuracy of all information provided. Additional fees for amenities or services may be charged by the hotel, resort or cruise line. Amenities or services may be discontinued or revised by the provider without notice. Hotels, resorts, ships or accommodations designated as wheelchair-accessible do not necessarily meet ADA requirements. Costco Travel is not responsible for inaccuracies or provider modifications.

Other Hotels in Fort Myers & Naples & Marco Island

Hyatt Regency Coconut Point Resort & Spa
Costco Member Reviews
4.7/5 (33 Reviews)
Costco Star Rating
4.0 Star Hotel
5001 Coconut Road, Bonita Springs, FL, 34134, United States
Escape to Coconut Point to enjoy family fun or a romantic getaway at this one-of-a-kind resort.

Learn More
Inn on Fifth
Costco Member Reviews
4.7/5 (10 Reviews)
Costco Star Rating
4.0 Star Hotel
699 5th Ave S, Naples, FL, 34102, United States
With a prime location in the vibrant heart of Naples, Inn on Fifth offers an exquisite setting for a stay.

Learn More
LaPlaya Beach & Golf Resort
Costco Member Reviews
4.5/5 (12 Reviews)
Costco Star Rating
4.0 Star Hotel
9891 Gulf Shore Dr, Naples, FL, 34108, United States
On a white-sand beach overlooking Vanderbilt Bay and the Gulf of Mexico, this high-end golf resort has breathtaking views. Step onto your balcony and take in the beach or bay views with your morning coffee.

Learn More
Naples Grande Beach Resort
Costco Member Reviews
4.4/5 (207 Reviews)
Costco Star Rating
4.0 Star Hotel
475 Seagate Dr, Naples, FL, 34103, United States
Serenely situated on 23 acres along Clam Pass and overlooking the white sandy beaches of the Florida Gulf Coast, this resort welcomes all travelers.

Learn More
Staybridge Suites at Naples/Marco Island
Costco Member Reviews
4.5/5 (29 Reviews)
Costco Star Rating
3.5 Star Hotel
9401 Triangle Blvd, Naples, FL, 34113, United States
The Staybridge Suites Naples Marco Island hotel is located in beautiful Naples Florida. The hotel is minutes from the pristine beaches of Naples and Marco Island and close to downtown Naples where guests will discover an array of shops and award-winning restaurants. Guests can also enjoy easy access to the best area attractions including Naples Botanical Gardens, Naples Zoo, Corkscrew Swamp Sanctuary and so much more.

Learn More
Sunseeker Resort Charlotte Harbor
Costco Member Reviews
4.3/5 (7 Reviews)
Costco Star Rating
4.0 Star Hotel
5500 Sunseeker Way, Charlotte Harbor, FL, 33980, United States
Relax and recharge at Sunseeker Resort Charlotte Harbor, a stunning new waterfront destination on Florida’s glittering Gulf Coast.

Learn More
The Ritz-Carlton Naples, Tiburón
Costco Member Reviews
4.3/5 (12 Reviews)
Costco Star Rating
5.0 Star Hotel
2600 Tiburon Dr, Naples, FL, 34109, United States
With sun-drenched greens and luxury amenities, The Ritz Carlton Naples, Tiburón inspires golf getaways in South Florida. Spend the morning playing the resort's two 18-hole courses designed by Greg Norman at Tiburón Golf Club. Or take to the water on a kayaking expedition before visiting the 19th green for evening cocktails. Additional amenities include a spa and a water park with three waterslides, a 600-foot lazy river and a children’s splash and play area.

Learn More
The Ritz-Carlton, Naples
Costco Member Reviews
Not enough reviews to display yet
Costco Star Rating
5.0 Star Hotel
280 Vanderbilt Beach Rd, Naples, FL, 34108, United States
Dazzling on Florida’s Gulf Coast, The Ritz-Carlton, Naples proudly debuts new experiences, extraordinary culinary offerings, and Florida's most iconic sunset.

Learn More
The Westin Cape Coral Resort at Marina Village
Costco Member Reviews
4.6/5 (51 Reviews)
Costco Star Rating
4.0 Star Hotel
5951 Silver King Blvd, Cape Coral, FL, 33914, United States
Become immersed in the blissful coastal lifestyle of The Westin Cape Coral Resort at Marina Village, nestled within the serene Tarpon Point neighborhood. This waterfront retreat offers breathtaking views of the Caloosahatchee River and Gulf of Mexico from every room and suite, complete with private screened balconies and full kitchens in suites. Guests can explore boutique shops and waterfront dining at Marker 92 or The Nauti Mermaid, enjoy on-demand activities like kayaking, nature trails, and complimentary dolphin tours, or unwind with three outdoor pools, two fitness centers, and a sauna. Combining dream home comforts with warm, genuine service, The Westin Cape Coral is designed to provide a restorative and memorable escape.

Learn More